Geoff McMahon climbed into and out of the Cehennem Dere by himself in
1973 without being
injured
Abich II is totally inaccessible
Bob Stuplich climbed downthe
Abich II and up the Abich II by himself in 2005 without being injured
If Ed Davis and his companions were near that location, then there would
have been substantial meltback of
the ice at the time, creating potentially new trails up from the bottom
Only some local natives know the location
Absence of evidence does not imply that local natives were lying –
“Fallacy of the Negative Proof”
Ed claimed to receive threatening calls from Islamic groups since he told
his story
Again, what evidence is there to show he was lying about this, especially
given 9/11 and the War on
Terror now?
Noah’s Ark materials and food in Abas’ shed
There is no
evidence to contradict Ed Davis and food is regularly found in
archaeology